The Cutting Edge

The official blog of Knife Depot

Knife group points out irony in WSJ knife article

If you’re a regular reader of the Wall Street Journal, a New York-based newspaper, you probably saw this small piece on great pocket knifes to own.

The irony of this article is that all of the knives they recommended would be “falsely deemed an illegal gravity knife by NYC District Attorney Cyrus Vance Jr.,” according to the group Knife Rights.

The knives featured in this article are the Benchmade Orange Griptillian, Gerber EVO serrated edge, Lone Wolf Knives Swale, Benchmade 470 Emissary, and Victorinox Swiss Army One-Hand Sentinel.

In accordance with the recent crackdowns by the District Attorney in New York City, even knives with liner locks are considered gravity knives in certain cases.

If you’re unfamiliar with the term gravity knife, among collectors it means a knife that locks open and closed within a handle. To law enforcement, it usually means one-handed knives that open easily. NYC is notorious for having some of the strictest and broadest definitions of gravity knife and what makes it illegal.

This controversy is sparking outrage in the knife community with some, including Laird Crawford’s letter to the editor in the May 2011 Blade Magazine, calling it a “scare tactic.”

In the November 2010 edition of Blade Magazine, there was a feature on the raids that were going on in NYC and how even lockbacks and box cutters were misidentified as gravity knives.

Knives are regularly demonized as deadly weapons even though they are useful tools for a number of jobs. The fact that people use them inappropriately at times doesn’t mean the right to own a knife should be compromised.

I think this finely written column by Simon Dingle, a journalist from South Africa, sums it up the best:

Society has a curious inability to differentiate between tools and the people who use them.

1 Comment

  1. It warps my attitude about these people outlawing any knife, period. They’re just extended gun-haters. I never have less than 2, usually 3 knives on me. Leatherman’s a given(1 of 3), and a small 2 blade, usually a medium 1 or 2 blade. They all have a purpose, and are used frequently. Everybody that knows me knows I have a knife within quick reach. If I go out amongst the braindead, there’s another one that’s ready for ‘rapid-deployment’, as one friend put it. Upclose and personal, it’s better than a gun. And legal without $400 in ‘training and permits. Another ridiculous thing I won’t go into.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

© 2023 The Cutting Edge

Theme by Anders NorenUp ↑